top of page

The Short -Term Savings Trap - Why DIY Plans Often Derail


ree

One of the most common short-term financial goals I hear from clients is: "I want to save up for X in 6-12 months." It could be a vacation, a wedding, or a down payment on a new apartment.

The idea is usually solid. But without a structured plan, those savings goals often fall apart — not because of bad intentions, but because life gets in the way.

Case Study: The Delayed Move

A couple planned to relocate for work and needed $8,000 for moving costs and temporary accommodations. They had six months to save. They figured they’d just "cut back a bit each month."

What happened:

  • No formal budget created

  • Extra income from freelance work went toward holiday gifts and a new TV

  • Only $3,200 saved by the move date

They ended up putting the remaining costs on a line of credit at 9.5%, which they’re still repaying two years later.

Where an Advisor Adds Value:

  • Breaks down the target into monthly savings goals

  • Builds a cash flow model to isolate the needed funds

  • Sets up automation so it happens consistently

  • Reviews spending leaks and underused assets

Why Short-Term Planning Fails Without Guidance:

  • No accountability or tracking

  • Unrealistic expectations of discipline

  • Underestimation of irregular or emotional spending

A financial advisor helps clients stay on track and adjust early — not after the deadline has passed.

Pros of Professional Planning:

  • Timely, achievable plans based on real numbers

  • Increased likelihood of goal completion

  • Protection from using high-interest debt

Cons of DIY Short-Term Planning:

  • Poor follow-through due to lack of structure

  • Frustration from repeated failures

  • Opportunity cost from missing a timeline (e.g., higher rent, missed home buying windows)

Sometimes, the cost of advice is far less than the cost of falling short.



 
 
 

Comments

bottom of page